Skip to content
Skip to content
Guides8 min read

AI-Generated Ads: Do They Work? Research and Examples

Do AI-generated ads work? What a 3,000-person study found, which commercials used AI, why McDonald's pulled its AI ad, and the rules you now face.

By Yuvraj Singh·Founder, Leaxor

A model picker listing AI video models and their credit costs, for a guide to whether AI-generated ads work

Turn your next topic into a finished video

Script, narration and captions, delivered as a finished vertical video.

Get started

Sources linked throughoutClaims checked against vendor docsReviewed November 2026

Short answer: AI-generated ads can work, but in the best public test I could find they did slightly worse than human-made ads on average. They did best on plain product briefs and worst where the ad needed a story or an emotion. And people mostly couldn't tell which was which.

Quick flag: I run Leaxor, which sells AI video models, so I'd quite like the answer to be "yes, always". It isn't.

What the research says about AI ads

The study I'd start with is from May 2026. Syracuse University's Newhouse School and Ipsos took ten brands, including Febreze, Visa and H&M, and paired a human-made ad with an AI one built from the same brief. 3,000 US respondents saw them.

The setup was tight. Gemini reverse-engineered each original spot into a brief, then Sora 2 made the new one, with what Ipsos calls "no human creative intervention".

MeasureResult
Against the sales benchmark (Syracuse)Human ads 11 points above, AI ads 5 below
Short-term effect (Ipsos)Human ads 14% stronger on average
Long-term effect (Ipsos)Human ads 17% stronger on average
Viewers confident an AI ad was AI13% says Syracuse, 25% says Ipsos
Viewers unsure either way40%

Those two detection figures describe the same study and don't match. I couldn't settle it, so you get both.

The useful finding is where AI held up. Syracuse says it "performed best when the brief was straightforward and product-driven", and struggled with "storytelling, emotion or a genuine point of view". Ipsos picks out Febreze and Herbal Essences as strong AI ads: a clear problem, a clear fix.

Ten pairs and one AI pipeline is a small sample, and Ipsos sells the testing tool used. Adam Peruta, who worked on it, also wrote the HBR piece with the blunt headline. I could only read its opening.

The other study points the opposite way. An experiment written up by MIT, with over 21,000 consumers on WhatsApp in India, found personalized AI avatar videos got 9.4% more clicks than personalized image ads and 6.5% more than a generic video. Its authors ask whether that came from "personalization or the novelty of the tech", and the ads were made "with heavy human involvement".

So these results aren't really in conflict. One tested AI with no humans in the loop against proper creative. The other tested AI with humans in the loop against cheaper formats.

Which commercials are AI-generated?

The famous ones, and how solid each claim is.

AdWhat happenedSource
McDonald's Netherlands, Christmas 2025Pulled after a backlashNBC News, Fox Business
Coca-Cola, Holidays Are Coming remakeRunway calls it one of the brand's highest-performing ads, citing System1Runway, a vendor
Kalshi, 2025 NBA FinalsReported as made for about $2,000 in roughly three daysBusiness Insider, via Runway
Toys R Us origin filmMade with SoraMarketing Dive, via Runway
Liquid Death, Veo 3 spotA fan-made spec ad the brand didn't commissionWebFX

I'd treat the Coca-Cola claim carefully, since it's from a company that sold the tools. Same page, same caution for Kalshi's $2,000.

The list is short because most AI in advertising never gets announced. A background swapped here, a product shot there. You won't find those in anyone's roundup, including this one.

The McDonald's AI ad, and what it cost

This is the one people search for, so here's what's on the record.

McDonald's Netherlands put a 45-second ad on YouTube in early December 2025. It was called "the most terrible time of the year", a rework of the Andy Williams song about how stressful the holidays can be. NBC News credits US production company The Sweetshop Films and the Dutch agency TBWA/Neboko.

People hated it. Comments went first, then the video went private days later. McDonald's told reporters:

"This moment serves as an important learning as we explore the effective use of AI."

The detail I keep coming back to is from The Sweetshop's chief executive, in a LinkedIn post since deleted and quoted by Fox from the New York Post: "Ten people, five weeks, full-time." The post said the hours "far exceeded a traditional shoot".

So it wasn't cheap, and it wasn't quick. A lot of people assume AI ads fail because someone cut corners. This one had a real team on it for over a month, and the ad still landed badly at the one time of year people are protective of what an ad should feel like.

Set that next to Kalshi at a reported $2,000, and the budget doesn't seem to be what decides it. McDonald's picked sentiment, the exact thing the Syracuse study found AI worst at.

Yes, with conditions that have got stricter this year. I'm not a lawyer, so treat this as a list of things to look up.

  • New York. Since 9 June 2026, ads with an AI "synthetic performer" must conspicuously disclose it. Cooley's summary gives penalties of $1,000 for a first violation and $5,000 after that, applying where the advertiser has actual knowledge. Audio ads and pure language translation are excluded.
  • EU. Article 50 of the AI Act lists 2 August 2026 as the start of its transparency duties for deepfakes.
  • US, everywhere. The FTC says claims "must be truthful, cannot be deceptive or unfair, and must be evidence-based". AI doesn't change that. If the render shows a blender crushing something your blender can't crush, that's your claim.
  • Meta. Ads get an AI info label when Meta's tools made them or when it detects third-party AI. There's more on that in my guide to Advantage+ creative.

Where I'd use AI in an ad, and where I wouldn't

Going by that research, I'd use it for product-led spots with one clear benefit. A shot of the thing, doing the thing.

Here's a real one. The coffee grinder clip on my AI ad generator page is a vertical studio shot, Veo 3.1, one render, no editing, and it cost $1.00. It has no story and it doesn't try to have one. That's about the ceiling of what I'd trust a model to do alone.

I also wouldn't ask it for the type. Video models can redraw labels and fine print, so the logo and price go on in an editor, and any real product should start from a photo of the real product rather than a description.

I'd keep AI away from holiday spots, anything built on a person's face and feelings, and anything where the story is the ad. A human writing the idea and AI rendering the shots is a different proposition, and closer to the MIT experiment than the Syracuse one.

Testing hooks is where the money argument is strongest. Drafts start at $0.10 on Seedance 1.0 Pro, so a bad idea costs you almost nothing. The tools built for this job are compared in the best AI video generators for Facebook ads, including several that do things mine doesn't.

Frequently asked questions

Do AI-generated ads actually work?+

On average they did worse than human-made ads in a May 2026 Ipsos and Syracuse University test of 20 ads, though the gap was small and AI did best on plain, product-led briefs. A separate experiment with over 21,000 consumers found personalized AI video beat other ad formats on clicks.

Which commercials are AI-generated?+

Known examples include McDonald's Netherlands' 2025 Christmas ad, Coca-Cola's Holidays Are Coming remake, a Kalshi spot aired during the 2025 NBA Finals and the Toys R Us origin film. Most AI use in ads is partial and never announced, so no complete list exists.

Is the AI McDonald's ad real?+

Yes. McDonald's Netherlands posted a 45-second AI-generated Christmas ad on YouTube in December 2025 and removed it after a backlash. McDonald's confirmed it, calling the episode an important learning.

Did McDonald's take down their AI ad?+

Yes. Fox Business reported that comments were removed first and the video was made private days later. NBC News reported that McDonald's Netherlands confirmed the removal by email in December 2025.

Are AI-generated ads illegal?+

No, but rules apply. New York has required a conspicuous disclosure for AI synthetic performers in ads since 9 June 2026, and EU transparency rules for deepfakes apply from 2 August 2026. In the US, ad claims must still be truthful and evidence-based. Get legal advice for your own case.

Can people tell when an ad is made by AI?+

Mostly not, in the Ipsos and Syracuse test. Syracuse reports only 13% of viewers of an AI ad were at least somewhat confident it was AI, while Ipsos's write-up of the same study says 25%. Both report 40% of viewers unsure.

Turn your next topic into a finished video

Script, narration and captions, delivered as a finished vertical video.

Get started

Yuvraj SinghFounder, Leaxor

Built Leaxor, an all-in-one AI image and video generator, to kill the two bottlenecks in publishing: 3–5 hours per short, and a second tool for every thumbnail. Now both take minutes.