Skip to content
Pencil alternative

A Pencil AI Alternative for Ad Creative You Pay For Per Image

Pencil's AI ad creative generator compared: features and pricing from its own pages, cost per generation with resizes, and when paying per image is cheaper.

By Yuvraj Singh·Founder, Leaxor·

Made in Leaxor

A phoenix opening its wings as embers stream off the primaries, head thrown back — painted with Leaxor
An enormous serpent coiled on itself, scales catching the light along one raised edge, head lowered and watching — painted with Leaxor
A bull elephant walking out of the dark, ears wide, tusks catching the light along their length — painted with Leaxor

Flux 2 Pro · See the image models

Editor's lead

Pencil is an AI ad creative platform: it generates static and video ads on models from OpenAI, Google, Adobe, Runway and others, scores them, resizes them for every placement and launches them to your ad accounts. Quick flag: Leaxor is mine, so read this with that in mind. Leaxor makes the images and clips without the ad layer around them, at $0.10 to $0.30 an image. Pencil's numbers below come from its own site, read on 17 November 2026.

01The full breakdown

What Pencil does

Pencil sells itself as "a creative marketing platform" that specialises in GenAI-driven ad creatives. It creates text, image and video ad assets, gives realtime AI insights and scores, and once you connect an ad account it adds predictive scoring and results dashboards. It resizes into 1:1, 9:16, 4:5, 16:9, 1.91:1, and launches and tracks ads on Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, YouTube, Google Display, DV360 and LinkedIn.

The enterprise side is a big part of the pitch: SOC 2 Type II, a no-train policy, IP ownership, role-based access, and case studies from L'Oréal and Unilever on its homepage.

Pencil pricing

From Pencil's pricing page, with annual billing in brackets:

  • Core: $14 a month ($11 annually), 50 generations a month, for solo entrepreneurs.
  • Growth: $55 a month ($44 annually), 250 generations a month, unlimited workspaces.
  • Pro: custom pricing, unlimited generations, bulk generation from feeds.

You can make six ads free through a guided sign-up. Unused generations don't roll over, Core and Growth can't go past their monthly allocation, and Pencil says it can't refund fees once you've upgraded from the free trial.

What a generation costs, worked out

Core works out to $0.28 a generation on monthly billing, $0.22 annually. Growth is $0.22, or $0.18 annually.

The resize rule changes that. Pencil says each new format costs one generation. One concept in all five of its sizes is five generations, which is $1.40 on Core monthly. On Leaxor an image is $0.10 to $0.30, and it renders 9:16, 1:1, 16:9, 3:2. It doesn't do 4:5 or 1.91:1, so for those you crop a 9:16 or 16:9 image yourself, at no charge.

Per picture, the two land in the same range. The difference is what you get for it: Pencil's generation includes copy, layout, scoring and the route to your ad account. Leaxor's is the picture.

Where Pencil is clearly ahead

Teams and governance. Workspaces, approvals, brand kits, scoring, enterprise terms, and launching into seven ad platforms from one place. If several people touch every ad, or legal has to sign off on it, Pencil is built for that and Leaxor isn't. Leaxor has free teams with a shared credit wallet, but no approvals, no scoring and no publishing.

Where Leaxor fits better

When you need product scenes and footage and you'll assemble the ad yourself. Leaxor has 46 image models that take your real product photo as a reference, and 24 video models from $0.10 a clip, all picked by name. There's no monthly allocation to use up: the smallest top-up is 500 credits, they never expire, and no subscription is required.

The AI ad generator page has real product renders with their prompts. To see Pencil next to AdCreative.ai, Creatify, Canva and Meta's own tools, read the best AI tools for Facebook and Instagram ad creatives.

Ready to try Leaxor?

Turn a prompt into a finished image in seconds.

Get started
02Which one is for you

Pick the one that matches how you work

Pick Leaxor if you want…

  • 46 image and 24 video models, picked by name
  • Pay per image, nothing to use up each month
  • Credits never expire, no subscription required
  • Product scenes from your real product photo
  • Free teams with a shared credit wallet

Stick with Pencil if…

  • Finished static and video ads, with copy
  • Predictive scoring once ad accounts are connected
  • Launches to seven ad platforms
  • Enterprise governance: SOC 2, no-train, IP terms
  • Six free ads to try it
03Feature comparisonLeaxor wins 2/7

Leaxor vs Pencil: features

FeatureLeaxorPencilWinner
Finished ad with copy and layoutNoYes
Creative scoringNoYes
Launch to ad platformsNo7 platforms
Sizes9:16, 1:1, 16:9, 3:21:1, 9:16, 4:5, 16:9, 1.91:1
Cost per image$0.10 to $0.30$0.18 to $0.28 a generation
Video models24, by nameFrom partners incl. Google, Runway, Kling
Unused allowanceCredits never expireGenerations don't roll over
04Pricing

Pricing: Leaxor vs Pencil

PlanLeaxorPencil
FreeNo free tier6 ads through a guided sign-up
Entry$5.00 top-up (500 credits)$14/mo Core ($11 annually), 50 generations
GrowthSame per-image price at any volume$55/mo Growth ($44 annually), 250 generations
TeamFree teams with a shared walletPro: custom pricing

Pencil pricing last reviewed November 2026. Verify on Pencil's site.

05The verdict

Pick Pencil if a team needs finished ads with copy, scoring, approvals and a launch button across ad platforms. Pick Leaxor if you need the product images and clips themselves, paid per render with nothing to use up each month.

06Questions

Pencil alternative — FAQ

How much does Pencil AI cost?+

On 17 November 2026: Core at $14 a month ($11 billed annually) for 50 generations, Growth at $55 ($44) for 250, and Pro at custom pricing with unlimited generations. Unused generations don't roll over.

Is Pencil AI free?+

You can make six ads free through a guided sign-up. After that you need a paid plan. Leaxor has no free tier.

Does Pencil charge for resizing an ad?+

Yes. Its pricing page says each new format costs one generation, across 1:1, 9:16, 4:5, 16:9 and 1.91:1.

Which AI models does Pencil use?+

Its homepage says it brings models from OpenAI, Google, Adobe, Runway and Stability AI, and its pricing FAQ names Anthropic, OpenAI, Google and Kling, among others.

Can Pencil publish ads directly?+

Yes. Core and Growth launch and track ads on Facebook, Instagram, TikTok, YouTube, Google Display, DV360 and LinkedIn. Leaxor doesn't publish ads.

Yuvraj SinghFounder, Leaxor

Built Leaxor, an all-in-one AI image and video generator, to kill the two bottlenecks in publishing: 3–5 hours per short, and a second tool for every thumbnail. Now both take minutes.

Get started

Make your first AI image today

Turn a prompt into a finished image in seconds.

Get started