How Top5s Makes Its Videos (and How Much It Earns)
Top5s is one of the longest-running mystery-and-paranormal listicle channels on YouTube, run by British creator Robert Atkinson. With 3M+ subscribers and a recognizable eerie-aesthetic format (dark footage, ambient drone music, calm voiceover, countdown structure), the channel has been a category leader since 2014. Here's how the videos are produced, an honest revenue estimate, and what aspiring creators should learn from a decade of channel survival.
Last updated: · Estimates based on Social Blade and 2026 niche RPM averages
How Top5s makes its videos
The Top5s format is built around a tight production formula: pick a mystery or paranormal theme, identify 5 cases that fit it, structure as a countdown from #5 to #1, narrate with calm voice over visually eerie footage. The visuals come from a mix of stock footage, public-domain news archives, and re-creations using royalty-free clips that match the unsettling tone. The musical bed is consistent across videos — drone-heavy ambient tracks that establish the channel's identity.
Production time per video is reportedly 8–15 hours, including research (finding 5 cases that fit the theme), scriptwriting (around 1,500 words for a 12-minute video), voiceover recording, footage assembly, and edit. The format has been refined over a decade — every step is templated, which is what allows 2–3 uploads per week from a small team.
The production workflow
Top5s appears to be operated by Robert Atkinson with a small support team — public credits and social media indicate roughly 3–5 people involved. Tools are conventional: Adobe Premiere Pro for editing, voiceover recorded in a home studio with broadcast-grade equipment, stock-footage subscriptions for visual material. The aesthetic consistency across hundreds of videos is enforced through a documented internal style guide rather than custom asset creation.
The British accent of the narrator is a structural advantage in the niche — paranormal and mystery content sounds more credible in a calm British voice, and the channel has leaned into this brand element heavily. Sister channels (Top5sFinest, Top5s Daily) extend the format with related content.
How much Top5s makes (estimated)
With 3M subscribers and 2–3 uploads per week averaging 400K views, monthly views are estimated at 5–10 million. The mystery/paranormal niche RPM range is $3–$8, lower than educational because of mixed advertiser comfort with the content category. At a midpoint $5 RPM and 8M average monthly views, monthly ad revenue lands around $15K–$40K.
Add Patreon revenue (publicly visible in the low-thousands monthly), occasional sponsorships from VPN and audiobook brands (the standard advertiser-comfortable categories for paranormal content), and merchandise, total annual revenue is plausibly $200K–$600K. After team costs and overhead, take-home for the operators is significantly less. These figures are estimates based on Social Blade view data and public RPM averages.
Why this format works
The mystery and paranormal niche has unusually consistent demand on YouTube — viewers actively search for "unsolved mysteries", "haunted places", "weird disappearances" year-round. Top5s captures this demand with an extremely predictable format: viewers know exactly what they're getting from the title, which converts well in search and recommendation feeds. The countdown structure also creates retention — viewers stay through #5, #4, #3, etc., to see what #1 is.
The format is also low-controversy and high-evergreen. Mystery cases from the 1900s remain interesting decades later, which means back-catalog views compound. A Top5s video published in 2018 still earns regular views in 2026, which is unusual on YouTube where most content decays quickly.
How to build a channel like Top5s in 2026
The mystery-listicle space is competitive but not saturated. New entrants can win by picking sharper sub-niches than the Top5s broad scope — specific historical eras (Victorian mysteries, 1970s missing persons), specific case types (maritime disappearances, lost civilizations), or specific geographic focuses (Pacific Northwest mysteries, British paranormal history). Within these tighter niches, a solo creator can compete with Top5s on depth.
The AI-first solo workflow: use Leaxor to generate atmospheric scene illustrations from your script, replacing stock-footage hunting. Record your own voiceover (the calm-narration tone is critical to the format), or use ElevenLabs voices that match the eerie aesthetic. Total per-video time drops from 8–15 hours to 2–4 hours, allowing solo publishing at 2–3 videos per week without burning out. The aesthetic won't be identical to Top5s but can be distinctly your own within the broader paranormal genre.
Common mistakes when copying Top5s' format
The most common mistake is going broader instead of narrower. New mystery channels try to cover every type of mystery — paranormal, criminal, historical, scientific — which positions them in direct competition with Top5s, Buzzfeed Unsolved, and other established players. Pick one specific lane (e.g., maritime mysteries only, or 19th-century unsolved crimes only) and own it.
The second mistake is using inappropriately upbeat music or visuals. The mystery/paranormal genre has strict aesthetic conventions — drone music, dark color grading, calm narration. Channels that try to "modernize" the format with bright music or fast cuts dilute the eerie-atmosphere appeal that audiences actively seek. Match the genre conventions even as you find your own voice within them.
Top5s — FAQ
Who runs the Top5s channel?+
Top5s is operated by Robert Atkinson, a British creator who founded the channel in 2014. The channel has grown organically over a decade with a small support team handling research, editing, and channel management. Atkinson serves as the primary voice (the calm British narration is recognizable across the entire catalog) and creative lead. The team is UK-based, which contributes to the channel's distinctive British-paranormal aesthetic. Atkinson has discussed the channel's history in occasional interviews and on Patreon, but the team specifics and revenue figures have not been publicly detailed. The channel has spawned sister channels (Top5sFinest, Top5s Daily) extending the format with related content categories.
How much does Top5s make per month?+
Top5s earns an estimated $15,000–$40,000 per month in YouTube ad revenue, based on 5–10 million monthly views and the mystery/paranormal niche RPM range of $3–$8. The lower RPM compared to educational or business niches reflects mixed advertiser comfort with paranormal and mystery content categories — many advertisers exclude the niche from their targeting. Adding Patreon revenue (low-thousands monthly based on public visibility), occasional VPN and audiobook sponsorships ($2K–$8K per integration for this size channel), and merchandise sales, total annual revenue is plausibly $200,000–$600,000 before team costs. After paying the small support team and overhead, take-home for the operators is significantly less. These are estimates based on public proxies; actual figures are not disclosed.
What music does Top5s use in their videos?+
Top5s uses ambient drone music with eerie/cinematic tones throughout their videos. The musical bed is consistent across the catalog — recognizable enough that long-time viewers can identify a Top5s video by music alone. The tracks come from royalty-free music libraries (likely Epidemic Sound, Artlist, or Audio Network based on production qualities) chosen specifically to match the unsettling-but-calm aesthetic of mystery content. Some early videos use original or commissioned tracks. Solo creators replicating the format can subscribe to the same music libraries (Epidemic Sound costs around $15/month for personal creators), which provide thousands of similar ambient drone tracks. The specific tone (slow, low-frequency, atmospheric without being melodic) is more important than the specific tracks for genre matching.
What software does Top5s use?+
Top5s uses standard professional video production software based on visible production qualities: Adobe Premiere Pro for editing and final assembly, Adobe Audition or Logic Pro for audio mixing, and stock-footage subscriptions (Storyblocks, Pond5, or similar) for visual material. Voiceover is recorded with broadcast-grade equipment in a treated home studio. Color grading is handled in Premiere or DaVinci Resolve to achieve the dark, desaturated aesthetic that defines the channel's look. There are no specialized or proprietary tools — the channel's success is in how those standard tools are used (consistent aesthetic, tight scripting, recognizable voice) rather than access to specialized software. Solo creators can replicate the entire stack with the same tools at consumer pricing.
Can I make a paranormal channel like Top5s with AI?+
Yes, partially. AI video generation tools (Leaxor, Pictory) work well for the listicle countdown format because the visuals don't need to be photo-realistic — atmospheric illustrations or stylized scenes match the genre conventions even better than stock footage in some cases. The harder element to replace with AI is voiceover. The mystery/paranormal genre depends heavily on calm, slightly somber narration; AI voice tools (ElevenLabs, OpenAI TTS) can match this tone now, but listeners often detect AI voices in long-form content and the genre's audience is sensitive to anything that breaks immersion. The pragmatic hybrid: use AI for visuals and pacing, record your own voiceover (or a real voice actor) to maintain authentic atmospheric narration. This combination compresses production time by 70% while keeping the irreplaceable human voice element.
More creator deep-dives
Build your channel
Start a channel like Top5s
50 free credits. No card. First animated short in under 10 minutes.