How The Why Files Makes Its Videos (and How Much It Earns)
The Why Files is the long-form paranormal and conspiracy channel run by AJ Gentile, with 4M+ subscribers and a fast-growing audience. The format combines narrative documentary structure with comedic side characters (the AI-animated 'Hecklefish' is a recurring co-host), 25–60 minute episodes, and extensive original visual content. It's mostly-faceless — AJ rarely shows his face but is the recognizable voice and personality. Here's how the videos are made.
Last updated: · Estimates based on Social Blade and 2026 niche RPM averages
How The Why Files makes its videos
The Why Files differentiates from generic paranormal channels through narrative structure and character integration. Each episode is structured like a documentary investigation: AJ presents a mystery, walks through the evidence, considers explanations, and lets the audience reach their own conclusions. The recurring animated character "Hecklefish" provides comedic counterpoint to AJ's earnest narration, breaking up long-form pacing with humor.
Production includes scripted narration, custom illustrated scenes (using consistent visual styling across episodes), animated character segments for Hecklefish, archival footage when relevant, and original musical score. Total production time per video is reportedly 60–120 hours of team work for a 30–45 minute episode, which is why publish cadence is 1–2 episodes per week despite the team size.
The production workflow
The Why Files team has grown over the channel's lifetime — public Patreon and social-media references suggest 5–10 staff including AJ as creative lead, a script-writing collaborator, motion graphics designers, character animators (for Hecklefish), and an editor. The visual style is consistent across the catalog because of internal style guides and asset libraries that have been built up over years of production.
Tools include Adobe After Effects for character animation and motion graphics, Adobe Premiere Pro for editing, Adobe Audition for audio mixing, and AI tools for some illustrated scene generation in recent episodes. The blend of human-written script, human voiceover, and AI-assisted visual production is one of the more sophisticated hybrid workflows on YouTube currently.
How much The Why Files makes (estimated)
With 4M subscribers and 4–8 long-form uploads per month averaging 2M views, monthly views land around 25–50 million across new releases and back-catalog. The paranormal/mystery niche RPM range is $4–$10, with The Why Files likely on the higher end because of the longer-form videos enabling multiple mid-roll ads. At a midpoint $7 RPM and 35M average monthly views, monthly ad revenue lands around $50K–$130K.
The channel runs a strong Patreon (publicly visible at $30K–$80K monthly), regular sponsorships from VPN, audiobook, and consumer-app brands ($8K–$25K per integration for this channel size), and a thriving merchandise operation centered on Hecklefish branding. Total annual revenue including all sources is plausibly $1.5M–$4M before team costs. Net take-home is significantly less after paying the team.
Why this format works
The Why Files solves the central challenge of paranormal content: how to be entertaining and credible simultaneously. Pure-skeptic content alienates the paranormal-curious audience. Pure-believer content alienates the broader market. The Why Files threads this needle by presenting evidence seriously, then letting Hecklefish poke fun at the most outlandish theories — which both honors the audience's interest in mystery and signals self-awareness to skeptical viewers.
The long-form structure (25–60 minutes) is also a deliberate algorithmic choice. YouTube heavily rewards videos that hold viewers for 20+ minutes with sustained recommendation push. The Why Files videos consistently retain 50–70% of viewers through 20+ minute marks, which is exceptional in any niche.
How to build a paranormal channel like The Why Files in 2026
The combination of long-form documentary + animated character is distinctive enough that direct copying produces obvious imitators. The applicable insight is the structural balance: serious narrative framework + comedic interruption that lets the audience laugh at the absurdity without breaking the investigation tone.
For solo creators, the AI workflow is feasible: use Leaxor for scene illustrations, hire an illustrator (or use AI character generation) for a recurring character that becomes your channel's animated co-host, record your own voiceover. Long-form production is the hardest dimension to compress — even with AI, a 30-minute video takes 6–10 hours of solo work minimum. Plan for 1 long-form video every 2 weeks if you're solo, supplemented with shorter cadence content between releases.
Common mistakes when copying The Why Files' format
The first mistake is copying Hecklefish-style character work without the underlying narrative structure. The character is funny; the channel works because the narrative investigation is solid. Imitators with comedic characters and shallow content fail to retain audiences past the novelty phase.
The second mistake is going too long too early. AJ has built audience trust over years that lets him hold viewers for 45-minute episodes. New creators starting at that length lose viewers in the first 5 minutes because there's no reason to invest 45 minutes in an unknown channel. Start at 12–15 minutes, build retention reputation, then extend length once your audience is conditioned to stay.
The Why Files — FAQ
Who is AJ from The Why Files?+
AJ Gentile is the host and creative lead of The Why Files, an American creator who launched the channel in 2019 to make long-form paranormal and mystery content. AJ has a background in radio and audio production, which contributes to the channel's strong narrative voice and audio quality. He rarely shows his face on camera (the channel is mostly-faceless, with occasional glimpses) but is the consistent voice and personality across every episode. AJ has discussed the channel's growth on Patreon and in occasional creator interviews, including the gradual team expansion as the channel scaled. The channel's growth from launch in 2019 to 4M+ subscribers by 2026 has been one of the faster-growing trajectories in the paranormal niche, driven by the unique combination of long-form depth and comedic character work.
How much does The Why Files earn per month?+
The Why Files earns an estimated $50,000–$130,000 per month from YouTube ad revenue, based on 25–50 million monthly views and the paranormal-niche RPM range of $4–$10 for long-form video formats. Adding the channel's strong Patreon presence (publicly visible at $30K–$80K monthly), sponsorship revenue ($8K–$25K per integration with multiple integrations per month for this 4M-subscriber channel), and merchandise sales (Hecklefish-branded merchandise drives significant revenue), total monthly revenue plausibly reaches $100K–$250K. Annual gross is in the $1.5M–$4M range. Net take-home after paying the 5-10 person team and overhead is significantly less than gross, but still represents one of the higher-earning long-form paranormal channels on YouTube. These figures are estimates based on public proxies — actual revenue has not been disclosed.
Who is Hecklefish?+
Hecklefish is the animated fish character that appears as a comedic co-host throughout The Why Files episodes. The character is positioned as AJ's skeptical and irreverent counterpoint — making jokes about the most outlandish paranormal theories while AJ presents evidence with earnest narration. Hecklefish has become one of the most recognizable mascots in the paranormal YouTube space and drives a substantial merchandise business for the channel. The character's animation is produced by The Why Files team using After Effects, with consistent character rigging that allows Hecklefish to react to scenes throughout each episode. The dynamic between AJ's serious investigation tone and Hecklefish's comedic interjections is the channel's signature structural element — it lets the channel cover potentially absurd paranormal claims while maintaining self-awareness about the absurdity.
What software does The Why Files use?+
The Why Files production stack includes Adobe Premiere Pro for editing, Adobe After Effects for the Hecklefish character animation and motion graphics, Adobe Audition for audio mixing, and broadcast-grade audio recording equipment for AJ's voiceover. The Hecklefish character is rigged in After Effects with reusable assets that allow the team to produce new character segments efficiently across episodes. Recent episodes have included some AI-generated illustrated scenes integrated alongside the human-produced visual content, suggesting the channel is selectively adopting AI tools for parts of production where they save time without compromising visual consistency. Solo creators replicating elements of the format can use the same Adobe stack, hire freelance character animators for a recurring mascot, or use AI character generation tools for similar effect at lower cost.
Can I make a paranormal channel like The Why Files with AI?+
Yes, partially. AI video tools handle the illustrated-scene portion of paranormal content well — Leaxor and similar platforms can generate atmospheric scenes from scripts that match the genre conventions. The harder elements to replicate are the narrative depth (which requires research and writing skill), the character animation (a recurring mascot like Hecklefish requires either custom illustration or specialized AI character tools), and the long-form pacing (holding 30+ minute audiences requires script craft that AI can support but not replace). The pragmatic hybrid: use AI for ambient illustrated scenes while still investing in script research and either hiring an illustrator or using consumer character-animation tools for your unique recurring character. Plan for 12–18 months of consistent posting before the channel reaches a critical-mass audience that can sustain long-form viewing.
More creator deep-dives
Build your channel
Start a channel like The Why Files
50 free credits. No card. First animated short in under 10 minutes.